Getting Reviews ~ My Experience with Reading Alley #WriterWednesday #BookReviews #AmWriting

reading alley 1

As an indie writer, I sometimes feel I spend more time researching how to get book reviews and begging for reviews than I do actually writing the books for which I need the reviews! I came upon Reading Alley during one of my gazillion research sessions and decided to give it a try. Reading Alley is similar to many of other review sites: it provides a community of independent reviewers who can submit reviews.

The first thing a writer needs to analyze when deciding whether or not to use a new review website is whether the website violates the Amazon terms and conditions, because Amazon reviews is the end goal after all. At Reading Alley, the reviewers do not receive any monetary benefits, although there is a rewards program. There is also no obligation to post the review on Amazon or any other commercial outlet. This is the important point because Amazon clearly states the following:

Book authors and publishers may continue to provide free or discounted copies of their books to readers, as long as the author or publisher does not require a review in exchange or attempt to influence the review.

~ Amazon Community Guidelines (emphasis added)

Reading Alley looked like it will be okay legally wise, but what about the cost? Initially, it didn’t sound too bad – $25 for a three-month review session. That’s cheaper than NetGalley and other similar sites. But wait! Don’t stop there. You can also promote your book to gain more exposure (front page of the website, in their weekly email, or on their Facebook page). It’s an additional $25 for a minimum of 10,000 impressions. I jumped on that as I’ve had issues before with paying huge amounts to be on a review site and getting almost no feedback. In the end, I paid $50 for a three-month review session including promotion.

What was my experience? First, let’s talk about Reading Alley itself. Their customer communication was good. I received an email each time a reviewer requested my book, a review was posted, or there was any other kind of feedback. I could check my dashboard at any time as well.

Reading alley 2

But what about the reviews, Dena? How did that go? A bit disappointing if I may say so myself. I had 10 reviewers request the book, 9 of whom downloaded and reviewed the book. I hear you thinking ‘that’s not bad’. That may be true, but only 4 of those reviews ended up on Amazon (one of which had already reviewed the book on Amazon). I know I can’t force reviewers to put their reviews on Amazon, but it’s disappointing nonetheless when it doesn’t happen.

In conclusion, I won’t be giving Reading Alley another try. Despite their good customer relations, the price is just not worth it for me. Guess I’ll keep searching for the magic formula for getting reviews.




Similar Posts


    1. This getting reviews things has me stumped, though. My hubby and I decided to spend more time/money/energy into trying to get reviews for Fat Girl Begone! as the initial reviews were good and the book is romcom (a more popular category than my cozy mysteries). But so far I’m not seeing much reward for these extra efforts. I have no idea how writers (who aren’t well known) get 50+ reviews.

  1. I didn’t know about Reading Alley, and it doesn’t sound like a bad idea. 9 new readers and 4 reviews sounds reasonable to me. I’ll Che l them out. Thanks for the information.

  2. I’ve heard about Reading Alley as well but have been hesitant to try it. Thank you for sharing your experience. 9 review requests and only 4 posted Amazon reviews doesn’t seem worth it to me. I guess I’ll keep searching for ways to get honest reviews. 🙂

  3. I have read a lot of articles on gathering reviews, Dena and it is one of the most frustrating things about being an author. I have read that only 3% of people that buy and read a book will leave a review. So when you consider that, the 4 reviews you got is probably not too bad. When I published my book, I gave out so many copies to hopefully gain reviews and only a very small percentage did. Be comforted in knowing you are not alone. 🙂

    1. Thanks! I’m unfortunately not alone. I try to write these blogs to help my fellow authors make informed decisions (read= not make the same mistakes I did). When I do a marketing push, I’m often able to get my book in the top 100 for a few days, but reviews? Nope. Nada.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *